‘People couldn’t deal with watching an animal die’: the strange saga of Timmy the whale – and how a whole country lost its mindNEWS | 21 November 2026What surprised Bodo Köpnick was how loud the whale was. “You could hear it as far away as the next village. It was eerie, but also impressive,” he says, then pauses to think how best to describe the noise a suffering humpback makes at night. “It was like a cow moaning. It went to your marrow.”
Köpnick, 65, is everything you would hope for in a volunteer fire chief on a sleepy holiday island: a grandfatherly figure who mostly spends his weekends teaching local children about health and safety, and letting them climb on the engines. But on 31 March his life was made infinitely more stressful by the appearance of a lost whale that had got itself stranded on the shores of his island of Poel, in northern Germany. It became his fate to stand on the shoreline and guard the huge creature while behind him an entire country lost its mind.
While Köpnick and his team took shifts gently spraying the animal’s exposed back with seawater, dozens of reporters gathered at a vantage point on a grassy hill. Behind them, beyond a rudimentary police barrier, a crowd of increasingly emotional people began to swell. Köpnick remembers these “whale friends” wearily: “They were always having a go at us, saying we weren’t doing enough to save the whale. It was stressful.”
A stream of footage produced by the visitors fed a frenzied online audience: the whale had been dubbed “Timmy” by comedian Hape Kerkeling in the guise of his comic character, grimy tabloid journalist Horst Schlämmer. Others had also given the whale the more abstract name “Hope”, but people eventually took to using both, to complete the animal’s anthropomorphosis with a full name: Timmy Hope.
Meanwhile, furious social media exchanges became wild conspiracy theories. The general thrust of this tsunami of content was that the authorities – and by extension Köpnick – did not have the animal’s best interests at heart. Some had decided he was spraying the whale with not water but acid, to dissolve its flesh so the state’s Ocean Museum Germany could acquire its skeleton.
It became apparent that the whale had become a screen on to which people were projecting their political grievances: one YouTuber suggested its skeleton would be sold “to give even more money to Ukraine”. (Poel is in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, a state where the Nord Stream pipeline was once a huge economic asset, and resentment about the German government’s support for Ukraine is particularly strong.)
Köpnick was at the frontline of this pressure, and was getting a little annoyed about it. The hairiest moment came one weekend after Easter, when a crowd burst through the police barriers and 100 protesters came running down the hill towards him. There were only two police officers on duty. “They said, ‘We can’t do anything for you now. Everyone has to save themselves,’” he says, half-amused at the memory.
At that point, Köpnick decided he’d had enough. He picked out two “pack leaders”, led them to his computer monitor and patiently explained what he was doing, that the hose with which he was watering the animal was not, in fact, a chain being used to tie it down, and that he was definitely not dousing the whale with acid.
For a man who had been the island’s fire chief since the days of communist East Germany, and usually had little more to do than rescue the odd holidaymaker who took a boat too far out into the Baltic, it was getting a bit much.
Big marine animals trapped in places they’re not supposed to be always make for a good spectacle. Their plight often stirs people to odd behaviour. Bukang-i, the shark that lost its way in a canal in Busan, South Korea, in October, attracted so many onlookers that would-be vigilantes in hi-vis vests appointed themselves its guardians. Willy, a northern bottlenose whale that mistakenly swam up the Thames for three days in January 2006, also attracted thousands of spectators eager to watch the doomed rescue attempt. Damon Albarn was moved to write a mournful song about it.
But the ordeal of Timmy the humpback triggered a uniquely intense derangement in Germany. Even the lurid jokes about the animal – as prevalent as expressions of anger and grief – seemed to inflate, not puncture, the hysteria, and it was hard to avoid seeing him as a vessel for the country’s fevered political climate. Like Timmy, people felt helpless and abandoned, and the government looked just as impotent – or, worse, seemed to be actively hindering rescue attempts. It wasn’t ideal that the drama unfolded in an election year in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, one of two eastern German states where the populist far-right Alternative für Deutschland was poised to make historic gains.
double quotation mark We saw it lift its head out of the water and look at us. There was definitely a will to fight in it then
As an eccentric team of philanthropists, far-right TikTokers, vets and animal rights campaigners rallied to save the whale, people saw their efforts as an act of defiance against an uncaring government. Meanwhile, the reflexive distrust of experts who insisted that the rescue was pointless echoed a recent, much bigger crisis – the pandemic.
Kai Arzheimer, a political scientist at the University of Mainz, describes a feeling of deja vu: “What reminded me of Covid was that there was a relatively broad spectrum of protesters, with a more leftwing, esoteric area on the one side and rightwing populist people on the other, who found common ground in the story of Timmy the whale.”
In the shallow waters on the Baltic coast, the authorities were struggling to get to grips with this extremely unusual situation. Whales of this size almost never beach themselves here, and when they do they are usually already dead or close to it. To have a helpless live animal, nearly 12 metres in length, lie in the bay for weeks on end was practically unprecedented.
On top of that, it looked very much as if Timmy was suffering. The Baltic is a long way from the humpback’s natural habitat in the Atlantic, and the salt content here is so low that if cetaceans spend too long in it, they develop freshwater skin disease, which causes pustules and ulcers that burst and crack, exposing the whale to fungus and bacteria. Horrific as it looks, the disease is not necessarily life-threatening: whales regenerate skin all their lives and look for things to exfoliate with, which is one reason they often get caught in fishing nets.
By the time Timmy had reached Poel, she had already beached herself several times. (It was not until the whole saga was over that everyone realised they had been misgendering her.) She was first sighted in the bay of Wismar, a large mainland town opposite Poel, dragging 20 metres of nets behind her, some wrapped round her head and body. Animal welfare organisation Sea Shepherd Germany, along with Greenpeace, eventually cut her free, an operation that Sea Shepherd campaign leader Flo Stadler says had to be carried out with great care. “The animal reacted with a lot of stress to human contact,” he says. “We could only try it a few times before the animal showed, by noises and by flapping its fins, that it wanted to be left alone.”
Sea Shepherd could not track the whale for long, and could not prevent Timmy from stranding herself near Timmendorfer beach, a resort 50km west of Wismar that provided the inspiration for her nickname. Here, off this sandy beach, the whale was stuck and impossible to ignore.
View image in fullscreen Bodo Köpnick, the volunteer fire chief who found himself looking after Timmy when she beached on his beat. Photograph: Florian Thoss/The Guardian
Enter Robert Marc Lehmann, a YouTuber, wildlife photographer, animal rights campaigner and veteran of several whale rescues, who gathered his team and filming equipment and – if his documentary is to be believed – used sheer force of personality to take charge of the operation to free Timmy. His credentials were, at least initially, enough to convince local mayor Sven Partheil-Böhnke to allow him to get involved.
Stadler seethes a little at the mention of Lehmann, and it is easy to see why. The YouTuber’s alpha-male energy, his declaration that he “might be the person in Germany with the most expertise for a situation like this” and the fact that he was obviously shooting a film as well as trying to save a whale clearly annoyed some of the scientists on the scene. In one tetchy exchange from the documentary, Stephanie Groß, of the Institute for Terrestrial and Aquatic Wildlife Research (ITAW), asks him, “What are you doing here?” Lehmann turns away in disgust.
But despite his abrasive presence, there’s no denying Lehmann took on a key role in the rescue operation. Standing at the whale’s head in a diving suit, he guided excavators as they dug an escape channel centimetres from her face. He also appears to have come up with the idea of gently prodding her further into this channel using the rounded side of the excavator’s shovel. In the film’s climactic night-time scene, Lehmann screams and stamps his feet at the whale to urge her to freedom.
After three days of effort, Timmy swam clear on the night of 26 March. But the relief was short-lived: the next day, she was spotted making her way not north towards Denmark and the North Sea but back east – to where she had just been. There were desperate attempts to use police and coastguard boats to guide her into open waters – partly led by Lehmann, who ranted against ITAW for refusing to let him take full command – but they failed, and on 28 March Timmy was back in the bay of Wismar, swimming around, hopelessly lost. Relations between Lehmann and ITAW broke down completely in a storm of recriminations. Lehmann took no further part in the rescue attempt – though he continued to comment on it on his YouTube channel.
Looking at a map of the islands crowded along this part of the German coast, it’s easy to see how the animal might have got stuck in the labyrinth of shallow channels. Humpbacks, unlike other whales, mainly use eyesight rather than echolocation to guide them, and there’s no sight of open water here. Timmy stranded herself several times over the next two days in the bay of Wismar, before heading north. But Poel is shaped like a horseshoe with the opening facing south; she swam straight into this dead end.
The bay, known as the Kirchsee, is barely more than 200cm at any point – not nearly deep enough for a 12-tonne whale to manoeuvre. Sea Shepherd was still keeping watch, as was Burkard Baschek, director of the Ocean Museum Germany in the nearby city of Stralsund, who coordinated efforts to coax the whale out of Wismar bay. A physicist and expert in ocean dynamics, Baschek is a lean, tall man who adheres strictly to scientific and academic principles, which had the drawback of making him come across as a little severe in interviews.
This was a new challenge for him, too: normally the museum is responsible for collecting and studying dead sea animals washed up on shore. No one was sure what to do with a living animal that, while weak, was showing no signs of dying anytime soon. Still, Baschek was convinced the multiple strandings showed she was sick, even if he couldn’t say exactly what was wrong with her.
The state of Timmy’s health at this point is the subject of much controversy. Those who attempted to rescue her insist she was fit and struggling to survive. So did the protesters, some of whom had travelled from across Germany to stand at the police barrier, and were weeping with grief and angrily declaring Timmy was a “fighter”. Others, including Stadler, maintain she was probably deliberately stranding herself in order to find a quiet place to die without drowning. Baschek reserves judgment: “There are indications that humpbacks do strand themselves when they are weak, but whether it was deliberate or it just got stuck can’t be answered.”
In any case, Baschek says he saw surprising signs of life in Timmy while she was swimming near Wismar in the last few days of March. “Somehow the rest had given it a chance to pool its strength,” he says. “We saw it lift its head out of the water and look at us. There was definitely a will to fight in it then.” But a day later, when Timmy was stuck in Poel, her energy was apparently gone. “It was significantly weaker,” Baschek says.
By this time, Till Backhaus, environment minister of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, had decided to take charge, setting up an office on the scene and appearing at press conferences and on the news almost every day, seemingly willing to talk to any media outlet or YouTuber. (That enthusiasm seems to have worn off: his office could not find time for an interview for this article.)
Having assumed his office in 1998, 67-year-old Backhaus is the longest-serving minister in any of Germany’s 17 state or federal governments, and in 1990 became one of the co-founders of the centre-left Social Democratic Party in East Germany. But even he had never experienced anything like the hysteria of the Timmy crisis. His first response was to do what most politicians would: order an expert assessment. This report, written in the space of a week by Baschek, Groß and another sea mammal expert from ITAW, came to a simple conclusion: the whale was weak and probably sick. The water was too shallow and not salty enough. And, given her skin lesions, any attempt to help would risk further harm. In a press conference, Baschek said further rescue attempts would amount to animal cruelty.
double quotation mark The issues are irrelevant; what’s important is the perceived enemies are the same: politicians, the media, scientists
Baschek stands by that report. “If we could have just transported it to the North Sea with a click of our fingers, its prospects would still have been extremely bad,” he says. Sea Shepherd and Greenpeace agreed, and called on the public to leave the animal to die in peace.
There was little chance of that. For many, the prospect of watching this huge animal slowly perish was too much to bear. The torrent of reels on YouTube, TikTok and Instagram did not let up. Much of the content was meant to be funny: a rock band attracted attention with a song called Blow Up the Whale. An online questionnaire helped users decide whether they were “Team Rescue”, “Team Leave” or “Team Kill”. But there were also expressions of grief and videos claiming the decision to leave the whale alone was proof of the corruption of the political establishment.
Katharina Nocun, a political scientist who specialises in conspiracy theories, says the affair was just another story for politically radical groups to exploit. “The same groups and individuals posted things about the farmers’ protests and Covid. A lot of the people who posted about Timmy had a pro-Russian attitude to the war in Ukraine, for example. The issues themselves are to an extent irrelevant; what’s important is that the perceived enemies are the same: politicians, the media, scientists.”
Backhaus, Baschek and anyone associated with the Ocean Museum or ITAW were condemned as murderers and death threats were hurled around, including at Stadler and the Sea Shepherd team. “It was a very loud, enraged mob of people who were suddenly supposedly interested in ocean and animal protection, but who basically just saw the animal as a pet,” Stadler says, still brimming with contempt. “People couldn’t deal with the prospect of watching an animal die.”
skip past newsletter promotion Free newsletter | Weekly Sign up to Inside Saturday The only way to get a look behind the scenes of the Saturday magazine. Sign up to get the inside story from our top writers as well as all the must-read articles and columns, delivered to your inbox every weekend. Enter your email Sign up after newsletter promotion
In the days after 1 April, it became clear the state was not going to do any more than provide palliative care for the whale – in the shape of Köpnick and his sprinklers. The public refusal to accept this coalesced into a privately funded, hastily organised, semi-improvised rescue attempt the likes of which had never been tried before with a marine animal of this size. It also succeeded – or not, depending on who you ask.
What made it even more extraordinary was the cast of characters involved, starting with the two millionaires who funded it: Karin Walter-Mommert, a racehorse breeder, and Walter Gunz, co-founder of one of Germany’s biggest electronic goods retailers.
It’s not clear what criteria this pair used to assemble their team, but it included a Peruvian author named Sergio Bambarén, who had written a bestselling novel about a dolphin’s quest for freedom and was nicknamed the “whale whisperer” because of his self-professed ability to communicate with Timmy. There was also a TikToker and former Hells Angel; a woman who ran a local limousine rental service; and a 22-year-old student who was appointed “technical director” after telling local reporters he believed the whale “deserved” to be rescued, then making suggestions about how it might be done.
Several vets offered their services. One flew in from Hawaii to spend several days, heavily jetlagged, giving advice before flying back under a cloud of acrimony. At least two members of the group had a history of support for Germany’s far right, and the press had a ball listing their many eccentricities and connecting them to the political fringes. Köpnick calls them a “dubious troop”.
View image in fullscreen Members of the rescue operation, including marine mammal biologist Pedro Baranda (front). Photograph: Action Press/Shutterstock
But the initiative also recruited experts, among them Jeff Foster from the Whale Sanctuary Project in the US and Pedro Baranda, chief marine mammal biologist and strandings coordinator for a Norwegian marine animal rescue organisation named Havdyrhjelpen. “It was a team that was so disorganised,” says Baranda, an avuncular Mexican with 36 years’ experience of rescuing whales and dolphins. “They had no knowledge, no compass, and were following the intructions of a ‘whale whisperer’.” Bambarén admits he is not a qualified marine biologist, but says his practical track record with whales gave him the requisite expertise.
Baranda neverthelss felt a rescue was worth a try. He agreed the whale was weak and disoriented, but was convinced she was healthy enough to survive. “This was a big challenge,” he says, “but it was an opportunity for learning – whatever the outcome.”
Other members of the initiative had their own motivations. Kirsten Tönnies, a vet with a small practice close to Frankfurt, had written a book that vehemently documented government mistreatment of animals – and what she regards as the complicity of the veterinary establishment. She is suspicious of how scientists handle animals – and of the commission’s report: “It was a joke. I got the feeling they didn’t look at the animal directly and just summarised what was already being said. What supposedly deadly illness did they find? It was still alive five weeks after they wrote that report!”
Then, on 15 April, the unexpected happened: a week after the report he commissioned was released, Backhaus changed his mind and announced the private rescue would be allowed to happen after all. It would be “tolerated” rather than “given permission”, so that any legal liability would remain with the initiative. The protesters rejoiced. In one video, a gushing crowd can be seen surrounding the minister on the shores of Poel, hugging the man they had been vilifying as a murderer.
People have different opinions about what caused Backhaus’s change of heart. Köpnick and Stadler think it was just another case of a politician giving in to the temptations of populism under massive media pressure. Baranda thinks Backhaus had a genuine moment of empathy. “As soon as he touched the whale, as soon as he understood it had the opportunity to survive … I have never seen a person change their expression in such a … magical way,” Baranda recalls. “His face lit up.”
For the next few weeks, the initiative rubbed the whale with zinc cream, covered her with wet sheets and experimented with pontoons and inflatables. Bambarén sang to the whale underwater, and says he saw her relax and form a bond of trust with him. Tönnies’ job was to write daily reports for the ministry and the financers. Köpnick watched proceedings with a drone, at the ministry’s request, but kept his distance. Timmy swam free at one point, but got herself stranded again. Another channel was excavated, then, finally, the whale was miraculously coaxed on to a barge – a kind of floating dock that opens at the back and can be filled with water, normally for transporting ships – that had been sunk as low as possible. News reports showed a state of near euphoria among the volunteers. It was 28 April, nearly two months since the whale had first been sighted, and a month since the government had effectively left her for dead. Unfortunately, it soon emerged that the barge was not wide enough for her to turn around in, which would prove a problem later.
Four vessels then set off for the North Sea, each with different captains. Most of the rescue team rode on the Fortuna B, which was towing the barge containing Timmy. Team members took it in turns to get in the water with her and gently rub her skin. “My impression was whenever someone was in with Timmy, the animal liked it, because it wasn’t alone,” Tönnies says.
View image in fullscreen Timmy being towed out to sea in a barge. Photographs: Philip Dulian/Picture Alliance/DPA/AP Images
She noticed Timmy did receive some injuries on the barge, but remains convinced that, while all animal transport is difficult and stressful, she suffered less than an average cow being transported to slaughter – one of the many cruelties she campaigns against. Foster, one of the whale experts drafted into the private initiative, wrote later that he noticed “several lacerations on the anterior portion of the head, likely caused by contact with exposed bolts along the barge walls”, as well as “additional abrasions on the head region and near the blowhole, likely due to contact with the straps holding the sandbags in the front of the barge”.
But the mood on the mission was souring, and the nerves of some of the crews were evidently fraying. A statement later released by lawyers representing the company that operated three of the ships complains of an “unclear command structure”, “contradictory instructions” and interference with their work.
The accounts of the private initiative and the shipping company are contradictory on several points, but on 1 May, with the ships north of Denmark but not yet in the North Sea, it was decided the whale would be released. The barge was towed forward with the back open in the hope that she would be washed out by the pull of the water. When that didn’t happen, the release was postponed until the following morning, when several people saw the whale being pulled out of the barge by ropes or hoses attached to its tail.
Foster was the only expert allowed on the barge for the release, and while he is now refusing to speak to the media, pending a possible legal action, he did leave a disturbing account on the Whale Sanctuary Project website: “The whale was forcibly dragged over sandbags within the barge with the pectoral fins fully extended, appearing to try to maintain stability while also causing visible distress.” Baranda, watching through binoculars from the Fortuna B, saw the crew “lasso” Timmy’s tail and drag her backwards out of the barge. “I’ve never seen something so barbaric in my life,” Bambarén says.
When they came back, Tönnies says, “Jeffrey Foster was standing alone, like a person in shock. He looked yellowish-green; he was trembling, pale.”
Baschek is not keen to talk about the specifics of the release. “The events spoke for themselves, other people should judge. We made our view clear beforehand: that a rescue made no sense and would amount to animal cruelty, because the risks were immense.”
Despite this, many, including Backhaus, insisted the mission was a success. The whale had been released alive – though she did not stay that way for long. According to the environment ministry’s analysis of tracker data, Timmy is thought to have died on 6 or 7 May, four or five days after her release, and a week before her corpse was found on the Danish island of Anholt, having travelled 215km. For whatever reason, it seems Timmy was heading not into the Atlantic but back into the Baltic.
Baranda maintains the whale was healthy when she was released. Both he and Foster said the tracker data shows she dived to a depth of 150 metres more than once, suggesting she was still strong and hunting for food.
The Danish authorities were in no hurry to examine the whale: she was dragged ashore a few days after being sighted on 14 May, and the autopsy carried out on 4 June, there on Anholt beach. By now the cadaver was yellow and bloated with gas from decomposition, and holidaymakers had taken selfies on top of the animal, triggering more outrage on social media. Some of Timmy’s bones were transported to the Natural History Museum in Copenhagen. In early June, a company called Daka Denmark confirmed to German media that it had acquired the rest of the cadaver and turned it into biodiesel and biomass for cement production.
The rescue operation is thought to have cost around €2m, but Walter-Mommert and Gunz have fallen out over the bill, the former accusing the latter of failing to pay all of his share. Walter-Mommert is being sued for €1.35m by a businessman who says he provided staff, equipment and organisational support for the rescue, but has not been paid. She wants him to clarify the circumstances of Timmy’s release first. In a statement made after the whale was set free, she wrote, “We hereby expressly distance ourselves from the events and the manner in which they led to the release of the whale.” The case has yet to make it to a court hearing.
Meanwhile, state prosecutors are sifting through hundreds of charges being pressed by members of the public over events related to Timmy. Some are directed against Backhaus, some at the private initiative, some at Ocean Museum staff. According to a spokesperson for the prosecutor, the charges are all related to Germany’s animal and environment protection laws, and accuse Backhaus of “failure to render assistance”.
The saga remains a media phenomenon. Timmy T-shirts and baseball caps are still on sale, as are Timmy-themed liquors made by a small distillery on Poel. The satirical play Timmy: Hope Dies Last is being performed at a theatre in Hamburg. It has been read as both a send-up of the media circus and a comment on how an anthropomorphised animal became a quasi-religious vessel for the hopes and dreams of an unsettled society.
Tönnies created more conspiracy fodder by briefly claiming DNA tests she commissioned showed the dead whale found on Anholt was not Timmy, though she admits she is not an expert in interpreting genetic tests. She maintains the initiative showed rescuing beached whales could be done – if only someone were willing to invest money into building a special rescue barge.
“Let’s not forget that the main reason we went there was to save a whale,” says Bambarén, who refuses to blame anyone. “This whale brought out the best and the worst of what we human beings are. It came to teach us humans about empathy, about kindness, about love, about forgiveness, and at the beginning we understood it, and unfortunately at the end, we failed.”
Looking back months later, Köpnick surveys the now empty bay of Poel. Turning away, he reflects, “If this had been in GDR times, the fishermen would have just gone out there and cut it to pieces and been done with it.”Author: Ben Knight. Source