Skip to content
Love to lift

Rocket Report: Starship may actually be near liftoff; China’s copycat booster designs

“This is not the outcome we were hoping for today."

Eric Berger | 250
SpaceX's Falcon 9 rocket is seen on the launch pad on January 9, 2023, ahead of its second OneWeb launch. Credit: Trevor Mahlmann
SpaceX's Falcon 9 rocket is seen on the launch pad on January 9, 2023, ahead of its second OneWeb launch. Credit: Trevor Mahlmann

Welcome to Edition 5.23 of the Rocket Report! It has been a difficult week for rocket aficionados, with the back-to-back failure of Virgin Orbit's LauncherOne, and ABL Space's RS1 vehicles, on Monday and Tuesday. I certainly hope both companies can find and fix the technical problems, and get into orbit soon.

As always, we welcome reader submissions, and if you don't want to miss an issue, please subscribe using the box below (the form will not appear on AMP-enabled versions of the site). Each report will include information on small-, medium-, and heavy-lift rockets as well as a quick look ahead at the next three launches on the calendar.

Virgin Orbit launch from UK fails to reach orbit. After the Cosmic Girl aircraft made a much-hyped takeoff from Cornwall, England, on Monday night, Virgin Orbit's mission ended in failure when the second stage did not properly put its nine payloads into orbit. In a statement published on Thursday morning, Virgin Orbit provided a little bit more information about the failure: "At an altitude of approximately 180 km, the upper stage experienced an anomaly. This anomaly prematurely ended the first burn of the upper stage."

Ars Video

 

Securing those assets ... This was the company's first failure after an initial demonstration mission, in 2020. Since then LauncherOne had successfully reached orbit four times in a row, indicating that the launch system was fundamentally sound. The failure comes at an unfortunate time for Virgin Orbit, which, Ars reports, is struggling to raise funds. After Virgin ceased a fundraising effort in November, it turned to founder Richard Branson for an additional $20 million in December 2020. However, this convertible note came with strings attached—it granted Branson a first-priority secured interest. Essentially, then, Virgin Orbit appears to have pledged all of its assets to Branson. (submitted by Ken the Bin)

ABL Space debut launch fails. The first flight of ABL Space Systems’ RS1 rocket failed to reach orbit on Tuesday, Space News reports. The company said that the nine engines on the RS1 vehicle's first stage shut down simultaneously after liftoff, causing the vehicle to fall back to the pad and explode. The company did not disclose when after liftoff the shutdown took place or the altitude the rocket reached. The explosion damaged the launch facility, but no personnel were injured.

Next attempt forthcoming ... “This is not the outcome we were hoping for today, but one that we prepared for,” the company said. The two-stage vehicle has nine of its E2 engines in its first stage and one vacuum-optimized E2 engine in the upper stage, using kerosene and liquid-oxygen propellants. The vehicle is designed to launch from facilities with minimal infrastructure and lift up to 1.35 metric tons to low-Earth orbit. ABL has raised several hundred million dollars from venture capital firms, with Lockheed Martin as both a strategic investor and a major customer. (submitted by Ken the Bin and EllPeaTea)

The Ars Technica Rocket Report
The easiest way to keep up with Eric Berger's and Stephen Clark's reporting on all things space is to sign up for our newsletter. We'll collect their stories and deliver them straight to your inbox.
Sign Me Up!

RFA to launch from Northern Scotland. The German launch company Rocket Factory Augsburg announced Wednesday that its debut launch would take place from SaxaVord Spaceport, located on the most northerly of the Shetland Islands in Northern Scotland. The Scottish spaceport is ideally located for RFA to launch payloads at a high cadence into polar Sun-synchronous orbits, the company said. According to the news release, RFA will have exclusive access to "Launch Pad Fredo" at the spaceport.

RFA One to fly this year? ... From an accompanying image, it appears that a large, steel launch support structure has already been constructed on site. (RFA calls the structure a "launch stool," but this family-friendly publication will use an alternative term.) The company says the debut launch of its RFA One vehicle could occur by the end of 2023 and that stage testing is due to begin during the middle of this year. We'll have to see if that happens, but it does seem like RFA's first orbital launch is not that far into the future. (submitted by Brangdonj, EllPeaTea, and Ken the Bin)

European launch race remains wide open. With the failure of Virgin Orbit's debut launch from the United Kingdom, the ability to proclaim oneself the first country and company to launch into orbit from Western Europe remains open. The RFA One launch noted above is one contender. Another is Isar Aerospace, which has an agreement to launch from the Andøya Spaceport in Norway, NRK reports.

Sweden, too ... The German company's Spectrum rocket can launch about 1 metric ton into low-Earth orbit, and Isar is attempting to make its debut orbital attempt this year. But wait, there's more. His Majesty the King of Sweden, Carl XVI Gustaf, will be visiting the Esrange Spaceport in the northern part of Sweden on Friday to "cut the ribbon" on an orbital complex there. However, an orbital launch tenant at Esrange has yet to be announced. (submitted by audunru)

Electron gets a new US launch date. After standing down in late 2022 due to weather issues, Rocket Lab has set a new launch date for Electron's first flight from Virginia Space’s Mid-Atlantic Regional Spaceport. The launch window for the "Virginia is for Launch Lovers" mission is scheduled to open on January 23, with backup dates through early February. The daily launch opportunity runs from 6 pm to 8 pm ET (23:00 to 1:00 UTC).

Hoping for calmer winds in the new year ... This mission will deploy three satellites for radio frequency geospatial analytics provider HawkEye 360. The mission is the first of three Electron launches for HawkEye 360 in a contract that will see Rocket Lab deliver 15 satellites to low-Earth orbit by the end of 2024. Electron's US debut was delayed by more than a year while the company sought to obtain a launch license, and the December attempt was scuttled by unfavorable upper-level winds during the launch window. (submitted by Ken the Bin)

SpaceX completes second OneWeb launch. OneWeb is now just two launches away from being able to provide broadband globally after SpaceX sent its latest batch of satellites to orbit on Monday, Space News reports. OneWeb said it now has 542 of 648 satellites in its proposed low-Earth orbit constellation. The company only needs 588 satellites to provide global high-speed broadband in places where it has regulatory approval to operate. The remaining 60 spacecraft will serve as a mix of in-orbit and ground spares.

An additional SpaceX rideshare mission ... SpaceX and New Space India Limited, the commercial arm of India’s space agency, are slated to perform one launch each early this year to enable OneWeb to provide global coverage. OneWeb last year ordered three and two launches from SpaceX and New Space India, respectively, to deploy the satellites needed to reach global coverage after suspending a contract with Arianespace to achieve this via Russian Soyuz rockets amid Russia’s war in Ukraine. OneWeb spokesperson Katie Dowd said SpaceX is also slated to launch an undefined number of spare OneWeb satellites on a rideshare mission by late summer. (submitted by EllPeaTea)

Roscosmos and Arianespace negotiating over Soyuz parts. After the Russian invasion of Ukraine, 36 OneWeb satellites that were to be launched on a Soyuz rocket were stranded at the launch site in Baikonur, Kazakhstan. Their fate has been uncertain, but now Russian Space Web reports that Arianespace representatives are exploring a potential deal with Roscosmos on the exchange of Soyuz rocket components stranded in French Guiana for the satellites.

A long road to recovery ... Due to severely curtailed ties between Russia and the West, even an exchange agreement in principle would leave challenging logistical obstacles. In the case of the Soyuz rockets, dozens of Russian specialists from the sanctioned RKTs Progress would have to obtain necessary visas and find a route to travel to French Guiana to support the preparation and loading of the Russian hardware on cargo ships for an 8,000-kilometer journey from the port of Cayenne to St. Petersburg.

Chinese launch company has some derivative designs. CAS Space is a Chinese company founded in 2018 and partially owned by the Chinese Academy of Sciences, the state-run national academy. In July, the company successfully reached orbit with the ZK-1A solid-fueled rocket, which is capable of lofting up to 1.5 metric tons into low-Earth orbit. Recently, the company released designs for a proposed "Powered Arrow" line of rockets. The designs are... something.

Ctrl-A, ctrl-c, paSte Space? ... Looking from left to right, in the image, one can see miniature versions of an Atlas V, an Antares, a Falcon 9, a Falcon Heavy, and at the far right, a New Shepard capsule. Let's be real for a minute. It is difficult to take a company like this seriously if they are simply going to wholesale ripoff the design of Western rockets. It's pretty ridiculous.

Starship launch attempt "soon," Musk says. Twitter owner Elon Musk took to Twitter on Thursday morning to post a photo of Starship sitting atop its Super Heavy rocket, rising above the coastal fog in South Texas. The photo was arresting, and Musk appended a short comment: "Starship launch attempt soon." Soon, of course, is a relative word in spaceflight. Musk has previously said that a launch attempt in late February is possible, and March is likely.

Why March seems possible ... Much work remains before Starship launches on Super Heavy, of course. The combined vehicle must undergo a wet dress rehearsal. Then the Starship upper stage will be removed so that the Super Heavy rocket can undergo a full static fire test of its 33 Raptor engines. (One report suggests this could happen on January 20). Then the vehicles must be re-stacked, and SpaceX must still receive its launch license. March seems like a probable time for launch, however. The month, after all, is named after Mars, the god of war. And my family has a spring break trip planned in the middle of the month. So yeah, March is likely.

Starship and Super Heavy on the launch pad on January 12, 2023.
Starship and Super Heavy on the launch pad on January 12, 2023. Credit: Elon Musk/Twitter

Pentagon set to release acquisition strategy. The US Department of Defense currently has an agreement to buy launch services for national security missions through fiscal year 2027—with United Launch Alliance winning 60 percent of contracts and SpaceX 40 percent. However, the military is already deep into planning what comes next and is close to releasing its requirements to buy services for the next period after that, The Wall Street Journal reports. This acquisition strategy could be released in February.

Is that what happened to Zuma? ... One of the new requirements, according to the report, is that launch companies be capable of fending off interference by China and Russia. It is unclear exactly what this means, but the Pentagon is apparently concerned about interference with rockets during launch and the deployment of satellites. Blue Origin is expected to be among the bidders for the next round of launch contracts, alongside ULA and SpaceX.

Blue Origin planning space tug for New Glenn. The Washington-based company is seeking to hire a "Blue Ring Senior Program Manager," Ars reports. Blue Ring is one of the projects being worked on at Blue Origin as part of the company's Advanced Development Programs. A number of these initiatives seek to augment Blue Origin's forthcoming New Glenn rocket, a heavy-lift vehicle that may make its debut in 2024. These programs include Project Jarvis, which Ars first disclosed in July 2021, to develop a fully reusable upper stage for the launch vehicle.

Customizable orbits ... Although Blue Ring is not as spectacular as a fully reusable second stage, it could nonetheless be an important component of making New Glenn a viable commercial vehicle not just for large government satellites but also for smaller satellites. The Blue Ring project combines two basic features: an EELV Secondary Payload Adapter, or ESPA ring, and a space tug. The space tug would allow ride-along satellites to reach different orbits than the rocket's primary payload, a service presently offered by other commercial companies on SpaceX's Falcon 9 rocket.

Next three launches

Jan. 14: Falcon Heavy | USSF-67 | Kennedy Space Center, Fla. | 22:55 UTC

Jan. 15: Long March 2D | Unknown payload | Taiyuan Satellite Launch Center, China | 03:20 UTC

Jan. 15: Falcon 9 | Starlink 2-4 | Vandenberg Space Force Base, Calif. | 16:18 UTC

Listing image: Trevor Mahlmann

Photo of Eric Berger
Eric Berger Senior Space Editor
Eric Berger is the senior space editor at Ars Technica, covering everything from astronomy to private space to NASA policy, and author of two books: Liftoff, about the rise of SpaceX; and Reentry, on the development of the Falcon 9 rocket and Dragon. A certified meteorologist, Eric lives in Houston.
250 Comments